What if the God has a line manager and yearly appraisals ?

We all know the ritual. You grind for 365 days, log every tiny win on your self-assessment, and try to convince your boss that you single-handedly saved the company. Why do we put ourselves through this stress? Simple: hard work pays for the lifestyle, dinner table upgrades, and overall well-being of our loved ones.

Whether it happens annually, half-yearly, or in quarterly sprints, the corporate machine always demands its sacrifice. We get evaluated, squeezed into a bell curve, and neatly labeled: Exceeds Expectations, Meets Expectations, or the dreaded Needs Improvement.

Now, given that over 90% of humanity believes in a higher power running the universe, a very reasonable corporate question arises:

What if God had a Line Manager?

Welcome to the annual strategic review at Cosmic HQ.

The Review Meeting

Manager: “Thanks for jumping on the call, God. Let’s dive straight into your FY25-26 appraisal. I’ve reviewed your self-assessment, but looking at the global dashboard, we have massive delivery failures.”

God: “I maintained 100% gravity uptime and kept the planet spinning at 67,000\mph

Manager: “Basic operational uptime is fine, but let’s talk about critical incident management, core governance, and UX.

First, climate SLAs are completely blown. We’re seeing massive landslides wiping out entire regions. That is a total failure of terrain stability and structural oversight.

Second, site safety at your flagship spiritual hubs. We’re seeing tragic stampedes during high-traffic events. When users are paying respect to your brand and getting crushed due to zero crowd management, that is a catastrophic brand risk.

Third, what’s going on with your ‘Premium Protection’ add-ons? Users install your official symbols and idols on their vehicle dashboards, treating them like guaranteed safety features, yet fatal crashes happen daily. If an antivirus software failed this consistently after a user bought the license, we’d be facing a class-action lawsuit for deficiency of service.

Fourth, where is the operational consistency in protecting people? One day, someone narrowly survives an accident and it’s labeled a ‘miracle.’ The next day, a hundred others in the exact same situation don’t get saved. In tech, if a security patch randomly works 1% of the time, we don’t call it a miracle—we call it a critical bug.

Fifth, look at the rest of the natural ecosystem. Millions of species across the animal kingdom survive, adapt, and keep the planet running in harmony without believing in any deity or needing faith modules. Users are looking at animals and asking: ‘If they can sustain an entire working ecosystem without this extra layer, why are we overcomplicating our core setup?’ You built a self-sustaining system there, but failed to scale that logical simplicity into other operational areas.

To make matters worse, the ‘New Generation’ segment isn’t accepting blind faith anymore. They demand logical data, real-time responses, and consistency. If you don’t secure product-market fit with them, this whole operation isn’t viable.

Standing by while the dashboard turns red is passive management, not leadership. What’s the official post-mortem on all this?”

God: “Well, I granted humanity free will—”

Manager: “I’m going to stop you right there. ‘Free Will’ was a feature in the beta release, but you can’t use ‘user error’ as a blanket excuse for a total lack of intervention.

Based on the data, I am placing you on a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP).”

Reality Check: What the Cosmic Review Teaches Us

When we step back from the story and look at real life, it’s clear that if any of us managed our professional projects with this level of unpredictable oversight, our badges would be revoked by Friday. Getting a top performance rating isn’t about relying on grand, cinematic gestures once a year—it comes down to the core fundamentals of daily execution:

  • Consistency over “Miracles”: High performers don’t rely on sporadic, unpredictable wins. They deliver steady, reliable, and reproducible results cycle after cycle.
  • True Ownership: When things go wrong, real leaders don’t point to “user error” or shift blame to legacy features (like Free Will). They take full accountability for the end-to-end outcome.
  • Proactive Risk Management: Waiting for the dashboard to flash red before acting is reactive. A top-tier rating requires identifying risks early, setting clear SLAs, and protecting your stakeholders before a crisis hits.
  • Adapting to the User: As expectations evolve—whether from a new generation of clients or leadership—staying relevant requires logical reasoning, transparency, and continuous alignment.

The Takeaway

When you step back and look at the sheer lack of intervention, it’s clear that if any of us managed our projects with this level of oversight, our badges would be revoked by Friday.

Leave a comment